What are the prospects for plant-based milks post-pandemic?

21 June 2021
video

So as the economy recovers what are the prospects for the plant-based dairy sector?

Plant-based milks are made from almond, hemp, coconut, rice, cereals, nuts, and soy plants which offer consumers several health benefits compared to dairy milk. They are widely used in applications such as beverages, milk, cheese, and ice cream and provide nutrients such as protein, fat, vitamins, and carbohydrates.

Positive perceptions

Plant-based milks are often seen as environmentally friendly products as their production emits fewer greenhouse gases and demands less land compared to the traditional dairy industry. A growing number of consumers opt for plant-based milk substitutes for medical reasons or as a lifestyle choice. Medical reasons can include lactose intolerance, which has a worldwide prevalence of 75%, and cow’s milk allergy.

However, the sector is not immune from controversy. Some specific raw materials are associated with environmental problems such as water stress (almonds) ecotoxicity and bee mortality, deforestation (soya) and mineral nitrate leaching. There are specific concerns over the environmental impact of almond milk. More than 80% of the world’s almond crop is grown in California, which has been in severe drought for most of this decade.

To supply almonds, farmers are ripping up relatively biodiverse citrus groves creating a monoculture fed by deep-water wells that threatens water supplies.

Complexities around dietary benefits

Dairy products are rich in calcium, iodine, and protein, and fortified with vitamin D, all of which are essential to a healthy diet. While not exclusively provided by dairy products, dairy is a key source of these nutrients, with dairy providing 38% of iodine intake in adults.

Cow’s milk has a higher nutritional value than most plant-based milks. Although perceived to be healthy the plant-based products available vary remarkably in their nutritional profiles; most have low protein, mineral, and vitamin content and the quality of the protein is less than cow’s milk. If these products are portrayed as substitutes for cow’s milk in the diets of young children, then protein content and bioavailability of the nutritional additives need to be considered by manufacturers and consumers. An Australian study found that plant milks tended to have a lower sugar content than cow’s milk but only one third contained similar calcium levels.

Off-flavours are another reported issue e.g., a beany flavour from soy, bitterness from seeds and poor texture characteristics. To overcome these issues plant-based milk manufacturers are working to add functional ingredients and more protein. For example, in 2020 Califia Farms launched Protein Oat in the US, which uses pea protein and sunflower seeds to make a product that is comparable to the protein value of cow’s milk.

A market that continues to grow

Despite these issues, consumers retain a positive perception of plant-based milks in terms of health, and this will no doubt continue to drive consumption. Recent research puts the rising consumption of alt-milks down to the healthy halo effect around nuts, the popularity of exclusion diets and the buzz about plant proteins.

More than half of Americans who purchase plant-based milk say they do so because it is healthier than cow’s milk (58%), tastes better than cow’s milk (54%), is better for the environment (53%), and/or reduces exposure to antibiotics and hormones (53%).

Lactose-free is another important attribute for plant-based milk consumers. The most successful plant-based milk brands to date have stressed a move away from the traditional and combined innovation with approachable activism. They have captured this increasing awareness of veganism, as well as rising concerns about nutrition and issues such as the environment.

Increased supply will continue to drive demand with manufacturers launching a greater range of products, from a wider range of ingredients.

Supermarkets and coffee shops are now offering a range of milk alternatives as standard in addition to more practical considerations, such as increased versatility and longer shelf life. There is a growing range of plant-based milks coming onto the market with different ingredients, with supermarkets and coffee shops now offering a range of milk alternatives as standard.

Food complementing modern demands

Many plant-based milks are shelf-stable, meaning they do not need refrigeration until opened. These benefits have been apparent during the Covid-19 pandemic. As government advice to stay home and long queues in supermarkets may increase consumer interest in shelf-stable products, the closure of restaurants, schools and businesses have led to substantial wastage of fresh foods such as milk.

As Covid restrictions ease and the global economy restarts, production and consumption of plant-based milks are likely to continue to grow, driven by environmental and health concerns, as well as other factors such as convenient storage and a growing range of product lines.

What are the prospects for plant-based milks post-pandemic?

21 June 2021

So as the economy recovers what are the prospects for the plant-based dairy sector?

Plant-based milks are made from almond, hemp, coconut, rice, cereals, nuts, and soy plants which offer consumers several health benefits compared to dairy milk. They are widely used in applications such as beverages, milk, cheese, and ice cream and provide nutrients such as protein, fat, vitamins, and carbohydrates.

Positive perceptions

Plant-based milks are often seen as environmentally friendly products as their production emits fewer greenhouse gases and demands less land compared to the traditional dairy industry. A growing number of consumers opt for plant-based milk substitutes for medical reasons or as a lifestyle choice. Medical reasons can include lactose intolerance, which has a worldwide prevalence of 75%, and cow’s milk allergy.

However, the sector is not immune from controversy. Some specific raw materials are associated with environmental problems such as water stress (almonds) ecotoxicity and bee mortality, deforestation (soya) and mineral nitrate leaching. There are specific concerns over the environmental impact of almond milk. More than 80% of the world’s almond crop is grown in California, which has been in severe drought for most of this decade.

To supply almonds, farmers are ripping up relatively biodiverse citrus groves creating a monoculture fed by deep-water wells that threatens water supplies.

Complexities around dietary benefits

Dairy products are rich in calcium, iodine, and protein, and fortified with vitamin D, all of which are essential to a healthy diet. While not exclusively provided by dairy products, dairy is a key source of these nutrients, with dairy providing 38% of iodine intake in adults.

Cow’s milk has a higher nutritional value than most plant-based milks. Although perceived to be healthy the plant-based products available vary remarkably in their nutritional profiles; most have low protein, mineral, and vitamin content and the quality of the protein is less than cow’s milk. If these products are portrayed as substitutes for cow’s milk in the diets of young children, then protein content and bioavailability of the nutritional additives need to be considered by manufacturers and consumers. An Australian study found that plant milks tended to have a lower sugar content than cow’s milk but only one third contained similar calcium levels.

Off-flavours are another reported issue e.g., a beany flavour from soy, bitterness from seeds and poor texture characteristics. To overcome these issues plant-based milk manufacturers are working to add functional ingredients and more protein. For example, in 2020 Califia Farms launched Protein Oat in the US, which uses pea protein and sunflower seeds to make a product that is comparable to the protein value of cow’s milk.

A market that continues to grow

Despite these issues, consumers retain a positive perception of plant-based milks in terms of health, and this will no doubt continue to drive consumption. Recent research puts the rising consumption of alt-milks down to the healthy halo effect around nuts, the popularity of exclusion diets and the buzz about plant proteins.

More than half of Americans who purchase plant-based milk say they do so because it is healthier than cow’s milk (58%), tastes better than cow’s milk (54%), is better for the environment (53%), and/or reduces exposure to antibiotics and hormones (53%).

Lactose-free is another important attribute for plant-based milk consumers. The most successful plant-based milk brands to date have stressed a move away from the traditional and combined innovation with approachable activism. They have captured this increasing awareness of veganism, as well as rising concerns about nutrition and issues such as the environment.

Increased supply will continue to drive demand with manufacturers launching a greater range of products, from a wider range of ingredients.

Supermarkets and coffee shops are now offering a range of milk alternatives as standard in addition to more practical considerations, such as increased versatility and longer shelf life. There is a growing range of plant-based milks coming onto the market with different ingredients, with supermarkets and coffee shops now offering a range of milk alternatives as standard.

Food complementing modern demands

Many plant-based milks are shelf-stable, meaning they do not need refrigeration until opened. These benefits have been apparent during the Covid-19 pandemic. As government advice to stay home and long queues in supermarkets may increase consumer interest in shelf-stable products, the closure of restaurants, schools and businesses have led to substantial wastage of fresh foods such as milk.

As Covid restrictions ease and the global economy restarts, production and consumption of plant-based milks are likely to continue to grow, driven by environmental and health concerns, as well as other factors such as convenient storage and a growing range of product lines.

Malachy Mitchell's featured publications

See All Posts

Food safety & security

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and food security

How can the impact of foreign investment be optimised to maximise benefits in terms of food security, while at the same time minimising risks to all stakeholders? 

Insight

Agribusiness

Coffee producers place faith in regenerative agriculture

Regenerative agriculture is seen as a genuine solution as coffee producers battle to protect their crops. But what makes regenerative agriculture so compelling a prospect?

Blog

Food safety & security

Health of children at the heart of UN food safety summit

The UN Food Safety Summit will assess why the food system continues to cause poor diet, malnutrition, undernutrition, obesity and child mortality prevails.

Blog
See All Posts

Join our latest webinar on climate change and food safety.

Get in touch with us or find an office closest to you.
Register now